Here's the thing about gifts: the sender chooses them, not the recipient. We can have norms around what gifts are appropriate, and agreements to not over-spend, and wishlists, and so on. But I won't always get the exact gift I want. Sometimes I didn't even want a gift. Sometimes the gift interprets JNDI strings in my log messages and executes random code from my LDAP server. This is the nature of gifts.
On the other hand, the best gifts are the things I never would have bought for myself, because they seemed too expensive or I didn't even realize I would like them or they were too much work to obtain, or because someone hand-made them just for me. These feel like luxuries of the sort capitalism cannot produce, because deciding, going out, and buying something for myself isn't luxury, it's everyday. It's lonely. It's a negotiation. It's limited by my own lack of creativity.
The best part of free software is it sometimes produces stuff you never would have been willing to pay to develop (Linux), and sometimes at quality levels too high to be rational for the market to provide (sqlite).
The worst part of free software is you get what you get, and the developers don't have to listen to you. (And as a developer, the gift recipients aren't always so grateful either.) Free software is a gift
The Gift of It's Your Problem Now
- What I built isn’t an ActivityPub system as much as a Mastodon-comp...from Tom MacWright
- Any software is considered free software so long as it upholds the ...from writefreesoftware.org
- Paradoxically, the one clear winner in all of this is Meta. Because...from Dylan Patel
- Part of what makes LoRA so effective is that - like other forms of ...from Dylan Patel
- In many ways, this shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone. The current r...from Dylan Patel
- Incentives are well aligned with the success of the open-source pro...from Filippo Valsorda
- Concretely, I exclusively offer ongoing retainer agreements, withou...from Filippo Valsorda
- Virtually all maintainers are either volunteers or full-time employ...from Filippo Valsorda