Instead, the basic principle I would like to see communicated to people is the idea that every form of authority and domination and hierarchy, every authoritarian structure, has to prove that it’s justified—it has no prior justification. For instance, when you stop your five-year-old kid from trying to cross the street, that’s an authoritarian situation: it’s got to be justified. Well, in that case, I think you can give a justification. But the burden of proof for any exercise of authority is always on the person exercising it—invariably. And when you look, most of the time these authority structures have no justification: they have no moral justification, they have no justification in the interests of the person lower in the hierarchy, or in the interests of other people, or the environment, or the future, or the society, or anything else—they’re just there in order to preserve certain structures of power and domination, and the people at the top. So I think that whenever you find situations of power, these questions should be asked—and the person who claims the legitimacy of the authority always bears the burden of justifying it.
from Noam Chomsky 📕
- The point is, it doesn’t matter what you read, what matters is how ...
- Actually, it reminds me in some ways of things that you find in non...
- You just keep being struck by the marvels of what you’re discoverin...
- Well, the drive to “advance”—I think you have to ask exactly what t...
- But the point is, for classical liberals in the eighteenth century,...
- View all
- To exchange one orthodoxy for another is not necessarily an advance...from orwell.ru
- Totalitarianism thrives, she continued, in conditions where people ...from Sara Hendren
- After 2008, there was a perception that the government was implicit...from Matt Levine
- But the thing about state-sponsored attacks is that they’re a bit l...from Matt Webb
- [CAP theorem](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAP_theorem) is perhaps...from apenwarr.ca
- As long as people think that government (as an ideal and an imperfe...from Matthew Gallaway
- Influence operations can take many shapes; most such operations are...from Casey Newton
- this is the problem when your sole governing ideals are destroying ...from INDIGNITY, from the makers of HMM WEEKLY